In 2025 the median Hillsborough single-family home sold for $5,564,000 and the median Burlingame home sold for $2,985,000. That's close to double. Divide each sale by the size of the house, though, and the gap nearly disappears. In 2025, Hillsborough's median price per square foot was $1,501 and Burlingame's was $1,449, a difference of about 3.6 percent, according to the San Mateo County Association of Realtors' 2025 annual single-family summary.
If you're choosing between the two towns, that changes the question. In 2025, Hillsborough's premium mostly paid for more house and much more land, not for a costlier square foot. Where the towns really differ is how a sale happens: how far over asking, how fast, and how many other homes you have to choose from.
The two medians follow house size
SAMCAR's 2025 figures, compiled by MLSListings, give the average home and lot size for each town. The average Burlingame home sold in 2025 was 2,282 square feet on a 7,962-square-foot lot. The average Hillsborough home was 4,423 square feet on a 30,635-square-foot lot.
Hillsborough's 2025 median price was about 1.9 times Burlingame's. Its average house was also about 1.9 times as large. Those two ratios line up closely. The lot ratio doesn't: an average Hillsborough lot in 2025 was close to four times the size of an average Burlingame lot.
Price per square foot here means sale price divided by the size of the house. The land is part of what the buyer pays for, but it isn't in the denominator. If extra land carried its own large premium, Hillsborough's price per square foot would sit well above Burlingame's. In 2025 it sat about 3.6 percent higher. In practice, a Burlingame buyer pays nearly Hillsborough rates for each square foot of house and gets about a quarter of the land with it.
Month by month, the lines keep crossing
A single year could be a fluke. The 2026 monthly reports show the two towns trading places on price per square foot through the year. In four of the ten months from January through October 2026, Burlingame's median price per square foot was higher than Hillsborough's. Those months were January, February, May and September.
Month (2026) | Burlingame median $/sq ft | Hillsborough median $/sq ft | Burlingame sales | Hillsborough sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|
January | $1,540 | $1,477 | 4 | 6 |
February | $1,707 | $1,480 | 12 | 6 |
March | $1,523 | $1,576 | 19 | 10 |
April | $1,522 | $1,643 | 25 | 15 |
May | $1,585 | $1,551 | 22 | 16 |
June | $1,566 | $1,741 | 20 | 16 |
July | $1,485 | $1,770 | 29 | 9 |
August | $1,584 | $1,749 | 13 | 11 |
September | $1,623 | $1,583 | 15 | 12 |
October | $1,629 | $1,704 | 23 | 10 |
Hillsborough recorded between 6 and 16 single-family sales a month over that stretch. With samples that small, one estate on a large parcel or one heavily updated house can move a month's median by a lot. A single month says little about either town. What matters is that across ten months the two towns stayed within the same band, roughly $1,480 to $1,770 per square foot. The most recent report, for October 2026, released by SAMCAR on November 12, puts Burlingame at $1,629 and Hillsborough at $1,704.
For context, the countywide figure is much lower. The San Mateo County single-family median in October 2026 was $2.2 million at $1,196 per square foot. In October 2026, a square foot of house in Burlingame cost about 36 percent more than the county figure, and that put Burlingame in Hillsborough's range.
Where the towns differ: the bidding
If the price per square foot is about the same, the difference between the towns shows up in how sales happen. The 2025 annual summary shows it plainly. Burlingame homes sold for 106 percent of list price after an average of 22 days on market. Hillsborough homes sold for 99 percent of list after an average of 35 days.
The 2026 monthly reports show the same pattern, with Hillsborough moving around more from month to month. Burlingame's share of list price received was between 105 and 110 percent in every month from February through October 2026, after 100 percent in January. Its months of inventory never went above 1.3 and fell to 0.4 in July. Hillsborough's share of list price ranged from 95 percent in January to 110 percent in February, with April at 97 percent and September at 98 percent. Its average days on market ran from 96 in January down to 8 in October, and its months of inventory ranged from 1.1 to 2.7.
For a buyer in 2026, that means two different kinds of offer. In Burlingame, the list price has worked more like an opening number. A buyer who needs to win usually plans for an offer well above it, often with a short window to decide. In Hillsborough, the outcome depends more on the house and the month. In October, Hillsborough sales averaged 108 percent of list after 8 days on market. In January, they averaged 95 percent of list after 96 days.
October 2026 was competitive in both towns at once. Hillsborough's 10 sales averaged 8 days on market at 108 percent of list. Burlingame's 23 sales averaged 20 days at 109 percent, with 0.7 months of inventory. A year earlier, in October 2025, Hillsborough homes averaged 62 days on market and sold for 98 percent of list. If you're watching Hillsborough, one month can look very different from the same month a year before. In Burlingame, the competition has looked about the same almost every month.
Burlingame's October headline mostly reflects bigger houses
The October 2026 median sale price was $3.51 million, up about 20.9 percent from $2,903,638 in October 2025.
The houses that sold were also bigger. The average Burlingame home sold in October 2026 was 2,484 square feet, up from 2,207 in October 2025, about 12.6 percent larger. The median price per square foot rose from $1,462 to $1,629 over the same comparison, about 11.4 percent. Larger homes selling in October 2026 account for much of the gap between a 21 percent jump in the median and an 11 percent rise per square foot.
An 11 percent year-over-year rise in Burlingame's price per square foot is still large. It also puts the October 2025 comparison in context. That month Burlingame trailed Hillsborough by about 14 percent per square foot, $1,462 to $1,665. By October 2026 the gap was about 4.6 percent. Because Hillsborough's monthly samples are small, that narrowing isn't a trend you can rely on. It does fit the full-year 2025 numbers and the month-by-month pattern above: the two towns now price a square foot of house within a few percent of each other.
What this means if you're choosing between them
Treat price per square foot as the shared baseline and decide what you're buying on top of it. A $3.5 million budget in Burlingame, measured against the October 2026 averages, buys a house of about 2,500 square feet on a lot near 8,000 square feet, a short trip from the shops and restaurants on Burlingame Avenue. In Hillsborough, at the same price per square foot, that budget buys a smaller house than the Hillsborough average, and the median Hillsborough sale that month was $6,075,000. The real choice is between Burlingame's typical house and lot and Hillsborough's much larger lots, which come with a larger budget. Our Burlingame and Hillsborough neighborhood pages describe how the two towns differ day to day.
Plan your offer for the town you choose. In Burlingame, the 2026 numbers point to having financing, inspections and a decision timeline ready before a house you want comes on the market. In Hillsborough, check that house's days on market and how many similar homes are for sale, because the room to negotiate has changed a lot from month to month.
A few quick answers
Is a square foot of house more expensive in Hillsborough than in Burlingame? Slightly over the full year. SAMCAR's 2025 annual figures put Hillsborough at $1,501 and Burlingame at $1,449. In four of the ten months from January through October 2026, Burlingame's median was the higher of the two.
How far over asking do Burlingame homes sell? Burlingame homes sold for 106 percent of list price across 2025. Every month from February through October 2026 was between 105 and 110 percent, and October 2026 was 109 percent.
Did Burlingame prices really rise 21 percent in a year? The October 2026 median was about 21 percent above October 2025, but the homes that sold were also about 12.6 percent larger on average. The median price per square foot rose about 11.4 percent over the same comparison.
If you're weighing a house in either town, or wondering where your own Burlingame or Hillsborough home falls against these numbers, The Mary Murphy Team can go through the recent sales near you square foot by square foot. Request a complimentary home valuation and consultation.
Mary Murphy | 650-773-4999 | [email protected] | Menlo Park and Atherton's trusted guide for life's next chapter
DRE# 00675838
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the median home price in Hillsborough vs. Burlingame in 2025?
According to SAMCAR’s 2025 annual single-family summary, the median Hillsborough home sold for $5,564,000 and the median Burlingame home sold for $2,985,000.
What is the price per square foot in Hillsborough vs. Burlingame?
In 2025, Hillsborough’s median price per square foot was $1,501 and Burlingame’s was $1,449, about 3.6 percent apart. In October 2026, Hillsborough was at $1,704 and Burlingame at $1,629.
Why is Hillsborough so much more expensive than Burlingame if the price per square foot is similar?
Mostly because the homes and lots are bigger. In 2025, the average Hillsborough home was 4,423 square feet on a 30,635-square-foot lot. The average Burlingame home was 2,282 square feet on a 7,962-square-foot lot.
Do Burlingame homes sell over asking?
Yes, consistently. Burlingame homes sold for 106 percent of list price in 2025. From February through October 2026, every month landed between 105 and 110 percent of list.
Do Hillsborough homes sell over asking?
It depends on the month. Hillsborough averaged 99 percent of list in 2025. In 2026, it ranged from 95 percent in January to 110 percent in February, and October came in at 108 percent.
How long do homes take to sell in Burlingame and Hillsborough?
In 2025, Burlingame homes averaged 22 days on market and Hillsborough homes averaged 35. Hillsborough swings more: in 2026, its average ran from 96 days in January to 8 days in October.
How do Burlingame and Hillsborough compare to San Mateo County overall?
In October 2026, the San Mateo County single-family median was $2.2 million at $1,196 per square foot. Burlingame’s $1,629 per square foot was about 36 percent higher than the county figure.
Did Burlingame home prices rise 21 percent in a year?
The October 2026 median was about 21 percent above October 2025, but the homes that sold were about 12.6 percent larger. Price per square foot rose about 11.4 percent, from $1,462 to $1,629.
Source: San Mateo County Association of Realtors (SAMCAR), data compiled by MLSListings.